   |
|
|
|
Does Proverbs
6:6ff contradict biological facts?
Regular reader "C." brought up this amusing complaint from "Skeptic X" that I thought was worth exposure. Here are the verses of concern:
Go to the ant, thou sluggard; consider her ways, and be wise:
Which having no guide, overseer, or ruler, Provideth her meat in the summer,
and gathereth her food in the harvest.
C. tells me that Skeptic X says that it is "blatantly untrue" that ants have no
ruler, because ants are divided up into castes and have a queen. But X is
missing the point here, as usual. We refer to ants having a "queen" and "castes"
but that is no more than a case of us imposing human terms analogically...i.e.,
anthropomorphizing. The queen ant is mostly just an egg factory the ants care
for; she doesn't make decisions like sending embassies to other anthills, etc.
(unless in response to an attack, which is also something instinctual) -- the
ants don't rule each other, or make decisions; it's all instinct, which is sort
of the point of Prov. 6:6! To compare the ant's "authority structure" to that of
a human government as though they were the same is simply ludicrous. C. also
figured this out and adds:
...(I)n context, Solomon is comparing human life (and the
tendency to be lazy) to ant life. Ants have an inborn industriousness that
does not need to be forced by having an overseer and ruler lord over
them...ants are born into a certain caste and just operate within that caste.
They don't need to be constantly be put back in their place by an overseer or
told to not be lazy by a commander. The queen...controls the numbers of ants
born into a particular caste according to the needs of the colony and is
basically the storehouse of information on cave-ins, food supplies etc. The
ants come to her and do the various jobs according to an innate
purpose.
C. has hit the mark. And Skeptic X? Well, it appears to me that he's been
watching Antz or A Bug's Life and been thinking that they are
documentaries! (But then, I've always compared X's level of Biblical
scholarship to that of a Disney movie!) |