Bruce Malina and Richard Rohrbaugh’s
“Social-Science Commentary on the Synoptic Gospels”


Page Contents:

[ Order Your Copy Today From Amazon.com ]

 
[ Go To Top Of This Page ]
Summary
Full Review Below
Book Reviewed Our Rating
Title:
Social-Science Commentary on the Synoptic Gospels
Author:
Bruce Malina and Richard Rohrbaugh
Binding:
Paperback, 422 pages
Publisher:

Fortress: June, 1993
ISBN:
0800625625
List Price:
$27.00
Buy Now For: $18.90
 (30%)
Buy This Book Now
From Amazon.com
Review Date:
14 June, 2002
Reviewer:
J. P. Holding
[ We Recommend This Book ]

Recommended for Advanced Interest Students

Book Description:

"When readers are separated from the social world of the author, miscommunication occurs. Historical methods of Biblical interpretation have been helpful in narrowing the gap between the modern reader and ancient authors but have concentrated only on distinctive events and ideas. The social-scientific approach employed in this commentary focuses on social phenomena that have persisted for centuries."

Bookshop Summary:  Another book useful for putting anachronizing skeptics in the outhouse, but marred by over-repetition.
 
[ Go To Top Of This Page ]

 
[ Go To Top Of This Page ]
Social Studies and the Synoptics


A review of Bruce Malina and Richard Rohrbaugh's Social-Science Commentary on the Synoptic Gospels

by
J. P. Holding
|

We've reviewed several useful works from the hand of Malina and others in what is called The Context Group and found every one of them useful. Social-Science Commentary on the Synoptic Gospels is no exception, but it is lower down on the scale than the others, for practical reasons.

This is another of those works that explains how the ancients thought compared to us today, and it uses the Synoptics as a guide. However, it could have been cut down by about 300 pages. Parallel Synoptic entries are generally given exactly the same comments in each case -- verbatim. Indeed some comments are repeated a half dozen times are more throughout the book. I like to read about things like the sort of bread the ancients ate, and how this colors the meaning of Jesus' words, but I don't need to read it more than once in the same book! A simple "see here" entry (which is used, oddly, in other places) would have been sufficient, especially considering that to do so would have cut the price of this book in half.

This work also has minor problems not found in other Context Group works. The authors appeal for example to the Mark 7:31 objection. The beginning matter also offers some intrusive political commentary about "Israeli brutality and inhumanity" against Palestinians that I feel has no place in a scholarly work about the Bible. However, the bulk of the information, beyond repetition, is quite helpful and insightful. We recommend this work for those engaging in depth study of the Bible from a social-science perspective.


[ Go To Top Of This Page

]